Saturday, 16 May 2020

The Mystery of Llywelyn ap Gruffudd


The Mystery of Llywelyn ap Gruffudd 
Dylan Hussey
MA Welsh History

Llywelyn ap Gruffudd is typically seen as the most powerful of all the medieval Welsh princes. He has been the topic of a number of academic studies, including J. Beverley Smith’s book Llywelyn ap Gruffudd: Prince of Wales. The image portrayed of him is that of a renowned warrior in his earlier years, and a great state builder during the creation of the Principality of Wales. Yet, there remains a number of questions about this somewhat elusive prince.


One of the most baffling, but simultaneously the least discussed, appears to be the fact that Lwelyn failed to marry until very late in his career. Smith notes this as ‘one of the most puzzling questions’ that comes up when looking at the life of the prince.  Not only this, but Llywelyn also did not have any illegitimate children (at least as far as we know) – which, for a Welsh prince, was quite a rarity, if not unheard of. He appears not to have had difficulty in fathering children, as the birth of his daughter in 1282 demonstrates, but this raises more questions than it answers. Contemporary sources are, for the most part, rather limited, at least in comparison to other places in Europe at the same time. As such, there is very little that can be said for certain about why Llywelyn made this decision, which so obviously jeopardised his achievements and his principality. However, speculation may lead to some insight not just as to one of the great mysteries of Llywelyn ap Gruffudd’s life, but also as to the way that historians perceive and subsequently treat the idea of homosexuality, particularly in the medieval era.

The idea of a medieval ruler being gay, or even bisexual, at first glance often sounds far-fetched, even to an open-minded historian. In many cases, the biggest argument against such a suggestion may be that there simply is not enough proof – which is indeed a valid concern, but a lack of overt evidence does not necessarily mean that everyone at this time, including rulers, were heterosexual. However, especially for nobility, marriage was often a political endeavour rather than a romantic one. Llywelyn, having lived through the turmoil of the succession crisis after his grandfather’s death, would have been acutely aware of the dangers that a troubled succession could bring. This swung both ways – too many heirs, such as the case with Owain Gwynedd, for example, would almost certainly lead to contested succession and bloodshed among those grappling for their father’s power. On the other end of the spectrum, having no male heir at all could lead to the endangerment and even disappearance of an entire political entity or dynasty.

Llywelyn would have experienced these harsh truths throughout his life, and yet he appeared to have been in no real rush to marry or to father children at all; his focus seemingly being on his military and political endeavours. His own letters are littered with reminders of the fact that the prince’s hard-won principality was likely to fall into the hands of the king were he to ‘die[s] without heirs of his body’.  And yet, his decision to marry Eleanor de Montfort only came truly into effect sometime after the discovery of a failed plot in 1274 by the prince’s own brother, Dafydd, and Gruffudd ap Gwenwynwyn of Powys to murder Llywelyn and install Dafydd as prince in his place. Historians acknowledge that this event likely brought into perspective the fragility of Llywelyn’s power without an ‘heir of his body’, but this does not explain why it took him until well past middle age to marry in the first place.

Was Llywelyn ap Gruffudd gay, or even bisexual, and did this contribute to his apparent apathy around finding a wife until the issue of succession became more crucial? Was this why he put off committing to marriage until the final few years of his life? It cannot be proven or said confidently, but it is one theory amongst a relatively small group of others. Despite this, the key may be determining whether such a lack of evidence stems from the impossibility of such a thing, the difficulties surrounding evidence for medieval Wales in general, or the secrecy that would likely surround that fact were it to be true. Indeed, running themes of secrecy and elusiveness are to be found when attempting to analyse any aspect of Llywelyn’s personal life and inner world. The fact that the mere suggestion that Llywelyn could have been gay or bisexual is unlikely to be taken seriously, however, is perhaps more of a reflection of the subtle bias that remains amongst academics against seriously exploring sexuality in the pre-modern age.

Speculation and assumption is always a dangerous game in any field, not just history, but in this case it can provide an interesting take on the way that historians could disregard the role that sexuality may have played in the lives of people in the medieval period.

Bibliography
Pryce, H. (ed.) with Insley, C., The Acts of Welsh Rulers, 1120-1283 (Cardiff, 2005), no. 407
Smith, J. B., Llywelyn ap Gruffudd: Prince of Wales (Cardiff, 2014, new edn.)

Homosexuality and Britain’s Stuart Monarchs, 1603-1714

Dr Tony Claydon
Professor of Early Modern History
t.claydon@bangor.ac.uk

Three Stuart rulers have been suspected of having had homosexual relationships, both at the time they were ruling, and in subsequent comment and scholarship. The case for James VI and I (king of Scotland from 1587, and king of England 1603-1625) seems the most convincing. Strong evidence (in the form of personal letters, and comment by courtiers on the king’s behaviour in public), appears to suggest sexual relations between the king and two of his courtiers. First, there was Robert Carr, the royal favourite from 1607 until his scandal-driven fall from grace in 1615; and George Villiers, the duke of Buckingham, who displaced Carr in James’s affections almost immediately. It is true that platonic male friendships in the early modern period could exhibit closer physical contact than we are used to today, and that the rhetoric used to describe such friendships has shifted in the intervening four hundred years. It is therefore right to be cautious before assuming that expressions of love and desire, or descriptions by others of intimate bodily connection, automatically prove what we would call homosexual activity. However, some of the sources are very difficult to interpret any other way, and the historian Michael Young has ridiculed the determination of some scholars to deny homosexuality in the face of the facts as we have them reported. 

The case of William III (reigned 1689-1702) is more problematic. He was certainly widely accused of homosexuality. He had come to the throne in the ‘Glorious’ revolution of 1688-9, which had displaced the previous king, James II, and the ejected monarch’s supporters, the Jacobites, levelled charges against William that he was sleeping with his two favourites. First there was William Bentinck, his long-standing friend from the Netherlands; and then Arnold Joost van Keppel, the handsome courtier who became close to the king from the mid 1690s. But, one might think, Jacobites would say this. The accusation of homosexuality was part of a wider polemical campaign, denouncing William for a litany of crimes, including tyranny, usurpation, treason against the nation’s interests, and bloodlust in pursuing his war with France. It is true that Bentinck warned William that his closeness to Keppel in the last years of his reign was being noticed and was giving the king a reputation for unnatural sexual behaviour. But, again, one might think he would say this. Bentinck was, by this time, the displaced favourite. He was disappointed and jealous having been ousted from a position of influence and as the monarch’s best friend and confidant. William’s chief of propaganda, Bishop Gilbert Burnet, idolised the king, but he did say in later memoires that William was blemished by a secret vice ‘of one sort’. This is suggestive, but Burnet never expanded what he meant, and may just have fallen for court gossip. Most of the rest of the evidence is circumstantial: there may have been no smoke without fire, or perhaps there was so much smoke that the lack of clear fire is telling.


The case of Queen Anne (reigned 1702-1714) is similar to William’s. She exchanged passionate letters with her childhood friend Sarah Churchill, who became duchess of Marlborough, and later with the courtier Abigail Masham. But these were less explicitly physical in their references than the correspondence between James and his likely lovers; and as was noted above, the language of ordinary affection in the early modern world can seem more erotic to twenty-first century eyes than its original authors intended. Popular pamphlets alluded to lesbian practices at court. But by the early eighteenth century the print industry had mastered the art of libellous character assassination, and - as the 2018 film The Favourite made clear (it was far more accurate in depicting general political atmospheres, than portraying unimpeachable historical detail, especially about royal sexual activities) - this was an age of deep and hostile faction, where one side would say almost anything about another. Churchill and Masham were from the opposed Whig and Tory parties, and so may have been caught in the vicious partisan crossfire of the era. Also, as with Bentinck, Churchill may have fanned rumours about her successor to the queen’s favour out of chagrin at her loss of place. As with William, there may well have been homosexual relations in the modern sense, but the direct evidence for such activity is questionable. 

What are the deeper historical lessons of this brief survey of Stuart homosexuality? At a first and most human level, in so far as physical sex occurred between monarchs and someone of the same gender in the Stuart age - or even if some of the relationships stopped at deep non-physical love - it is a reminder of variety and ambiguity of human emotion, even at court. It can be difficult to categorise people’s sexualities into neat slots, especially with patchy source records; the ways we talk about love and sex have shifted radically since the early modern era, and it is worth noting that all the monarchs we have covered, and all the favourites, contracted heterosexual marriages, whatever their private proclivities. Many of those marriages worked at the political level, and some were personally successful too. William III was utterly distraught when his wife Queen Mary II died; Sarah and John Churchill were a formidable team; Robert Carr appears to have been prepared to murder to be with the woman of his choice (this was the scandal that ended his career). Second, the common accusation of homosexuality levelled at monarchs reminds us of the highly personal nature of rule in the Stuart era. This period has been presented as being marked by the rise of parliament, the press, and the power of the people exercised through a vigorous public sphere. This is true to an extent, but the efforts put into establishing the monarch’s personal affections, and advertising any perceived defects in them, remind us that this was a world in which politics still mostly happened at court, political action centred on a still very influential monarch, and the individual personalities of courtiers still very much mattered. The ruler’s personal reputation for virtue was essential for their rule, and attacks on it were serious. People needed to know who the monarch was close to, the basis of that relationship, and how to undermine the standing and respect given to rivals or enemies. Finally, though, the trajectory of discussion of royal sexuality may indeed point to a period where a wider public was becoming more important. James VI and I’s sexuality was mainly discussed in a narrow and elite circle, which played factional games of access, exclusion, and libel to gain influence. By Anne’s time, however, discussion was in a widely read press, and was a tool of mass political parties with supporters in every community in the land.

Bisexual Erasure…

Even From Those Within The LGBTQ+ Community
Lydia Carter
MA Sociology

Most of you probably know what I am talking about when I say: ‘Bisexual Erasure? Definitely a Thing’. For those who don’t know- which is fine, everything is a learning curve- ‘Bisexual Erasure’ refers to a pretty common tendency of those both outside of and within the LGBTQ+ community to ignore, remove, or re-explain blatant evidence of bisexuality. This evidence might exist in history, academia, literature, or news media. Oscar Wilde? Bi as heck, guys. The most extreme extent of this erasure is the belief that bisexual people simply do not exist, which is almost definitely an excuse that I am going to use for my next assignment. ‘Why is my submission late? Well, I don’t exist!’.

The most recent example of bisexual erasure that I have seen, happened only recently when the activist and celebrity Jameela Jamil came out as queer on Twitter. Although there’s absolutely nothing wrong with this, India Willoughby, transgender newsreader, broadcaster, journalist and reality television personality, did not agree. She promptly accused Jameela Jamil of what can only be regarded as queerbaiting, accusing her of attempting to draw in an audience for a Reality TV Show that Jamil was due to judge on. The show will focus on bringing the ballroom culture of the 80’s and 90’s that still exists today to mainstream culture. Pushing aside the fact that Jameela Jamil has acknowledged her sexuality on the internet before, because this shouldn’t matter, one part of Willoughby’s Tweet stood out: ‘She’s got a boyfriend’.

Why does that matter? I’m a bisexual woman and have never had a girlfriend. Does this mean I ever doubt my sexuality? Of course not! I know bisexual people who have only ever dated those of the opposite sex. Does this make them heterosexual? No. I know bisexual people who have only ever dated those of the same sex. Does this make them homosexual? Can you guess? No, it doesn’t.  

It is bad enough that so much of history, and so many parts of the world today, have made it nearly impossible for people to live freely within their sexuality or gender. History is littered with voices that were kept quiet because of something as simple as their sexuality. I have always viewed the LGBTQ+ community as a place of freedom, of love, and of pride. To this day, I will say that the safest I have ever felt is when I visit London for Pride. There is no hate, no judgement, and certainly no one telling others how to express themselves.

To have somebody attack a woman who has been forced to state her sexuality publicly, in response to those who were angered by her appearing on a ballroom-based television show, is bad enough. But to then have that person, who purposely attempts to erase Miss Jamil’s sexuality based on their own prejudiced opinion, identifying as a member of a community that should spread love and not hate, is simply not on. 

One can choose to pick a label and identify as that, with bisexuality, pansexuality, sexually fluid, queer or purely ‘not doing labels’:  these are all different ways to identify and indicate that you are not exclusively attracted to either men or women. I could elaborate on the fact that many people refuse to acknowledge the differences between bisexuality and pansexuality, but I’ll leave that for now. Jameela Jamil has identified as queer, and it is our job to support her in that fact. We should celebrate that we live in an age where ‘coming out’ is far easier than it used to be- while acknowledging that it is not this way for everyone- especially for a non-white woman. 

Gay, straight, transgender, non-binary, bisexual, pansexual, asexual, queer – be whatever you want to be, and allow others to be those things, too. The world has enough problems without spreading hate when there should only be messages of encouragement and love.

Drug F***ed

Chemsex in the LGBT Community in Wales
Tadgh Crozier  
BA Health/Social Care and Criminology/Criminal Justice
 tdc18qbb@bangor.ac.uk 

On average, one person dies every 12 days from the use of GHB (gamma-Hydroxybutyric acid). Chemsex is the use of three drugs to facilitate sexual activity between gay men: GHB, Crystal Meth (Methamphetamine) and M-cat (Mephedrone), and it is facilitated within the gay community across the United Kingdom. Not only are people dying from the use of the drugs involved in Chemsex, but this process has also been attributed to the increase in rates of infection of HIV and sexually transmitted infections in gay men.

Drugs and sex have been intertwined in the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) community throughout modern history, and this is especially true within the community of gay men. Studies have highlighted that the community is at three times greater risk of substance abuse than those who identify as heterosexual. A substantial proportion of this drug use is associated with sexual activity. So why is Chemsex / sexualised drug use a much more significant problem in the LGBT community than in the heterosexual community? Also, what is being done about it? Although there are many reasons given for the increased use and risks, this article will focus on two of the main reasons.




1. Internalised Homophobia
Growing up a gay man in a straight man’s world takes its toll and being told that the sex you are having is wrong will have an impact. The messages that are created by a 'hetero-normative' society can lead to a range of internalised feelings such as hurt, guilt and inadequacy, to name but a few.

 

Messages in the media, such as those emblazoned in the headlines in Figures 2 and 3, teach the LGBT community that they are different from the rest of society. This may result in gay men feeling disconnected from both the rest of society and each other. These negative messages are perpetuated across society, creating little cohesion and acceptability of difference. Messages such as: ‘It’s not Adam and Steve, it's Adam and Eve’ have also been used as an argument to justify that homosexuality is abnormal, which can result in gay men feeling excluded from society.

The use of Chemsex within the Gay community has been seen as a way of connecting with other gay men in times where there were very few places to meet in a safe environment. It also allows a level of intimacy while taking back control of the sex that gay men have been told for so long that they shouldn’t have. If Chemsex is used safely then why shouldn’t its use continue? Isn’t this a form of empowerment to an already disenfranchised community?

Systems and institutions have perpetuated an inferiority message throughout the years, for example in healthcare settings, regarding donating blood. Gay and bisexual men who practise safe sex with other men have to wait three months before giving blood, while heterosexual men do not. These messages bring feelings of shame and trauma, which are then internalised and manifest in damaging ways, such as in higher rates of suicide and a higher risk of substance misuse, including through Chemsex.

2. The lack of specific or LGBT-competent services 
Evidence has shown that there is a need for more LGBT-competent and specialist services so that this community can access support to address their substance misuse issues, including via Chemsex. There is a fear of having to disclose sexuality and being judged because of it, which then becomes a barrier to accessing support.

However, this is only part of the issue. Since the introduction of the 2010 Equality Act and the 2013 Marriage Bill, societal attitudes towards homosexuality have begun to change, but there is still a need to challenge inequality. LGBT people accessing health care services continue to report that due to lack of knowledge about their specific needs, and the assumption of heterosexuality, they are still experiencing dissatisfaction in healthcare, especially compared to the heterosexual community.

Is chemsex / sexualised drug use a public health issue in Wales?
The rise in sexually transmitted infections and late-diagnosed HIV has prompted Public Health Wales to look into the impact of sexualised drug use, including Chemsex, in men who have sex with men (MSM). However, the current drugs strategy for Wales has no mention of gay men and, therefore, a clear pathway for service users is yet to be set. Wales appears to be stumbling in its handling of the Chemsex issue.
 



It is difficult to know how many people are engaging in Chemsex, and without this data it is challenging to commission appropriate services.  However, at present, no services are providing specific Chemsex support in Wales. The nearest Chemsex services are in London or Manchester, which are the only two LGBT-specific services in the United Kingdom. This means that people in Wales needing support may not be able to access it.

Closing thoughts
Having to continually prove the right to exist can take its toll on the LGBT community, and this is evident with continual reports that LGBT people are at a higher risk of suffering from mental health issues.

At a time when gay liberation and freedom was taking place, another reason for ‘acceptable’ homophobia came along in the 1980s: HIV and AIDS.  This was initially called the GRID: gay related immune deficiency. This period in time seemed to give a green light for society to blame and stigmatise an already weakened community. The only way to support LGBT people to lower the risk of poor mental health, and save lives, is for individuals and institutions in society to be more accepting of differences. 

Has Chemsex and other sexualised drug use been an accumulation of years of homophobia? Is the minute support for people using Chemsex in Wales evidence of a lack of insight, or a sign that institutionalised homophobia continues well into the 21st century?


Fig: 1. https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/vdxny9/an-illustrated-a-to-z-of-chemsex-903
Fig: 2. https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2018/02/16/daily-mail-columnist-richard-littlejohn-attacks-gay-parents-pass-the-sick-bag/

Fig: 3. https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2018/11/30/world-aids-day-1980s-headlines-tabloids/

Fig: 4.http://www.wales.nhs.uk/sitesplus/documents/888/Quarterly%20Report_Apr2019_v0a.pdf

Friday, 15 May 2020

LGBTQ+ in Gypsy, Roma and Traveller Communities

Tersa Crew and 'Guinevere’
Senior Lecturer in Social Policy and Social Sciences Student
t.f.crew@bangor.ac.uk

Introduction

It is well documented that Gypsy, Roma, Traveller (GRT) communities face inequalities in health, housing, employment and education, as well as the worst racism and prejudice of any minority group (See Cemlyn et. al, 2009; Brown and Scullion, 2010; Heaslip, 2015; McFadden, 2016,18; Condon, 2019 for further details). This focus on inequalities, while much needed, means there is scant research on intersections of the GRT identity, for instance with sexuality.   

While there is little empirical research or statistics to evidence the experiences of LGBTQ+ people within GRT communities, anecdotal data tells us that homophobia is a hidden issue.  Many will hide their sexual identity due to fear of rejection by family and their community, and because of their religious beliefs (The Traveller Movement, 2017: 2-5). 

The following narrative from ‘Guinevere’ adds an important addition in understanding some of the discrimination that LGBTQ+ Gypsy Travellers can face within their own community.

‘Guinevere’s’ Story

‘It’s your punishment, if you had married a man God would have let him live but a woman marrying a woman is a sin and now you’ve been punished, be wise Guinevere, you’ve been given a chance to turn away from temptation and marry a man, or you’ll end up burning in hell with her.’

Two days after my wife died, I sought solace in the church. I went to a Nawken-born priest, who had known me my entire life, from my Baptism to my Confirmation. As I cried in the house of God, he spoke those words to me. It was that day that I turned my back on the Catholic faith and the community I was born into. 

It is a common misconception that all Gypsies are the same, or that we only fall into two categories, Romani and Irish Traveller. However, the actual number of different groups of Gypsy Travellers is currently unknown.  If I was to venture a rough guess, I’d say it consists of between 100-200 different groups. All of these groups have their own distinct histories, practices and beliefs. As such its important to understand not every Gypsy Traveller group find the practices of people in the LGBTQ+ community to be wrong. Unfortunately, within the UK, Traveller communities that are largely pro-LGBTQ+ are uncommon. 

In recent years Gypsies have become something of a fascination among the gorger community, with television shows like My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding in the UK and US giving viewers a snapshot into their lives and cultures.  American Romani Gypsy Ana, whose wedding to her female partner was featured in Episode 8 Season 2 of the US series, stated in an interview for the show that ‘In our culture, that (being gay) just doesn’t happen. It would be like a black guy in the Ku Klux Klan.’ The show’s production team chose to show an interesting contrast through the two weddings in this episode, with the second marriage being one between two first cousins.  This highlighted the fact that it was more acceptable to commit a type of incest then be a lesbian in Gypsy culture.  While many of the struggles faced by Ana and her fiancée were not necessarily unique to the gypsy community - such as wondering if her immediate family were going to be in attendance for the ceremony - the show highlights the harsh realities LGBTQ+ Romani gypsies often confront.

Being gay and out in the Romani community is an isolating reality: not everyone is as lucky as I have been.  My family all but left the community in support of my choices, but this, unfortunately, is a rare occurrence. A fellow gay Romani, Mikey Walsh, author of the Gypsy Boy: The bestselling memoir of a Romany childhood and Gypsy Boy on the Run was not only forced out of the community for being gay, but for many years after releasing his first book had to go into hiding from people his own father had sent to ‘deal with him.’ In theory, within the UK a father wanting to kill his own son for being gay would be considered an extreme case, however, in our community entire families can end up being rejected because of one person being homosexual. More often than not, the only choice if you want to live openly is to leave the community behind and build a life as a gorger.  Though slowly attitudes are changing, there is still a long way to go before our community is ready to accept us for being anything but ‘dirty’.

Bibliography

Brown, P., & Scullion, L. (2010). “Doing research” with Gypsy–Travellers in England: Reflections on experience and practice doing. Community Development Journal, 45,
169–185.

Cemlyn, S., Greenfields, S., Burnett, S., Matthews, Z., and Whitwell,., (2009). Inequalities experienced by Gypsy and Traveller communities: A review.  Equality and Human Rights Commission. 

Condon, L., Bedford, H., Ireland, L., Kerr, S., Mytton, J., Richardson, Z., & Jackson, C. (2019). Engaging Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller Communities in Research: Maximizing Opportunities and Overcoming Challenges. Qualitative Health Research, 29(9), 1324–1333.

Heaslip, V., 2015. Experiences of vulnerability from a Gypsy/Travelling perspective: A
phenomenological study. (PhD). Bournemouth University. 

McFadden, A., Atkin, K., Bell, K., Innes, N., Jackson, C., Jones, C., MacGillivray, S., and Siebelt, L. (2016). Community engagement to enhance trust between Gypsy/Travellers, and maternity, early years’ and child dental health services: protocol for a multi-method exploratory study. International Journal for Equity in Health,15, 183 

McFadden, A., Siebelt, L,. Gavine, A., Atkin, K., Bell, B., Innes, N., Jones, H., Jackson 2, Haggi, H., MacGillivray, S. (2018). Gypsy, Roma and Traveller access to and engagement with health services: a systematic review.  European Journal of Public Health. 28(1):74-81.

The Traveller Movement (2017). LGBT Gypsies and Travellers: Our Stories.  [Online, available from: https://travellermovement.org.uk/advocacy-support/lgbt